Articles | Protis Global

Protis Global vs. Heidrick & Struggles: Which Search Firm Fits Consumer Brands?

Written by Lars Miller | Nov 14, 2026, 2:00:00 PM

Last updated: November 5, 2026

Protis Global and Heidrick & Struggles both run retained executive search, and the resemblance thins out fast after that. Heidrick is one of the five largest search firms in the world, built around board and senior executive mandates across every major industry. Protis Global works only in consumer brands and runs retained search at every level, from analyst to board, on milestone-based installments.

This comparison covers what each firm does well, where the two models part ways, and which mandate belongs where. Protis Global wrote it, so read the Heidrick section as the honest case we would make for hiring them, with sources linked throughout.

Protis Global vs. Heidrick & Struggles at a glance

Heidrick & Struggles is a global leadership advisory firm with three lines of business: executive search, on-demand talent, and leadership consulting, strongest at board and C-suite level. Protis Global is a retained search specialist that covers consumer brands only, fills roles at every level, and ties fee installments to a slate you approve.

Dimension Heidrick & Struggles Protis Global
Scale Fifth largest global search firm per Hunt Scanlon; $239.1M in executive search revenue in Q3 2025 alone Specialist firm; 3,000+ placements over 30+ years, all in consumer brands
Industry focus Every major industry, including consumer markets as one practice among many Consumer brands focus, though can and will do searches outside this niche: non-alc beverage, beer, wine and spirits, food and snacks, health and beauty, pet, packaging, cannabis, food tech, robotics
Role levels Built around board, CEO, and senior executive mandates, plus interim placements through On-Demand Talent Every level: analysts, field sales team members, national account executives, retail execution managers, sourcing managers, directors, VPs, C-suite, board
Ownership Privately held since the $1.3B take-private backed by Advent International and Corvex Independent, people-first firm; Building Companies. Changing Lives.®
Fee structure Conventional retained engagement; confirm installment triggers in your contract Milestone-based installments tied to a slate of talent you approve to interview
Client cadence Varies by engagement and practice Standing weekly candidate review meeting with every client, every search

What Heidrick & Struggles does well

Heidrick & Struggles is a global leadership powerhouse. The firm reported $322.8 million in total revenue in Q3 2025, up 15.9 percent year over year, with $239.1 million from executive search, and it completed a $1.3 billion take-private transaction backed by Advent International and Corvex Private Equity. Chicago stays home; the brand and leadership continue.

The numbers describe real strength: global reach across offices and markets, deep board and CEO networks, and two capabilities a pure search firm does not carry, interim executives through On-Demand Talent and leadership assessment and culture work through Heidrick Consulting. A multinational that needs a CEO search run across three continents, with succession assessment layered on top, is squarely in Heidrick's lane. Revenue figures come from Hunt Scanlon's report on Heidrick's Q3 2025 results.

What Protis Global does differently

Protis Global has spent 30+ years exclusively in consumer brands and runs retained search at every level where those companies hire: analysts, field sales team members, national account executives covering retailers like Kroger, Albertsons, and Walmart, retail execution managers, sourcing managers, directors, VPs, the C-suite, and the board. The record: 3,000+ placements, 48% diverse placements, $754M in client economic impact.

Recent searches show the range. National account roles supporting Kroger and Albertsons for a food and beverage brand. A retail execution manager for world renowned beer brands. A sourcing manager at a better for you beverage brand. A Senior Brewery Manager intake at Mark Anthony Brewing. In one search for a pet-health brand, the team screened more than 800 professionals to produce 3 offers, part of the 9,395+ first-round interviews Protis recruiters have run.

Two mechanics hold every engagement together. First, a standing weekly candidate review meeting, where you see profiles, conversation summaries, and compensation expectations, and you decide who interviews. Second, milestone-based installments: the second installment triggers only when the firm presents a slate of talent, typically 2 to 3 people, and you approve them to interview, with the final installment paid upon placement. You have a say in when the second and third installments are paid. The firm has made Hunt Scanlon's America's Top 250 Recruiting Firms for three consecutive years, and the full process is laid out in our approach.

Three differences that decide the choice

1. Category depth against global breadth

Heidrick brings breadth: every industry, every major market, one firm. Protis Global brings depth in one category, and in consumer brands that depth shows up in screening. A recruiter who has spent years in beverage can tell the difference between a candidate who ran 140 brands across six distributors and one who presented someone else's results.

That fluency is the practical difference in the weekly review. In current state manager searches for a national spirits supplier, every candidate write-up carries compensation detail set against the client's internal ranges before anyone books an interview, so the client rules on real tradeoffs instead of resumes.

2. Where in the org chart the firm actually works

Heidrick's search practice is built around the top of the house, and its On-Demand Talent arm covers interim needs. Protis Global runs the same retained process for a field sales team member that it runs for a CEO, which matters to consumer brands because most hiring pain sits below the C-suite: the national account seat at Walmart, the retail execution manager, the sourcing lead whose vacancy stalls a launch. Protis' sister company ace Talent Curators can also offer on-demand interim and fractional talent as well. 

One engine, every level, also means succession work connects down into the org. In one current COO succession search for a family-owned beverage distributor, the client's executive team uses the weekly review to weigh steady-hand leadership against transformational change candidate by candidate, while the search team verifies compensation and vesting details between calls. How that staging works is covered in executive search for succession planning in consumer brands.

3. What the fee schedule rewards

At many firms the calendar dictates milestone payments: 30 days pass, an invoice arrives, whether or not you have met a candidate worth hiring. Protis Global ties the second installment to a slate you approve to interview and the final installment to placement, and you have a say in when the second and third installments are paid.

The stakes justify the scrutiny. Brad Smart's Topgrading research cites a Chief Executive Magazine analysis putting the cost of a mis-hired CEO earning $1 million at $27 million, roughly 27 times salary, once wasted compensation, disruption, and missed opportunity are counted; the figures are in Brad Smart's mis-hire cost analysis. The vacancy math is in retained search ROI for consumer brand hires, and the contract clauses worth reading first are in 7 things to know about retained search for CPG.

When Heidrick & Struggles is the right call

Choose Heidrick & Struggles when the mandate is global and sits at the top of the organization: a public-company CEO or board search spanning multiple markets, a leadership team assessment attached to a transformation, or interim executive coverage at enterprise scale. A diversified industrial or financial services company hiring across industries gets real value from one global partner.

When Protis Global fits better

Choose Protis Global when the company is a consumer brand and the roles span the org chart: a first COO or CPO at a scaling brand, national account coverage for named retailers, retail execution and sourcing roles, or a succession plan that has to connect the board seat to the bench below it. Sequencing guidance for younger brands is in first C-suite hires for emerging consumer brands, and the Poppi case study shows the work inside a fast-scaling brand.

For a wider field of options, two structured comparisons cover the market: the 2026 comparison of retained search firms for consumer brands and how to choose a retained search partner in 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Is Protis Global a good alternative to Heidrick & Struggles for consumer brands?

Yes, when the mandate sits inside consumer brands. Protis Global has run retained search exclusively in consumer categories for 30+ years, covers every level from analyst to board, and ties fee installments to a candidate slate the client approves. For global multi-industry board work, Heidrick's scale is the better match.

Does Heidrick & Struggles work on roles below the C-suite?

Heidrick's executive search practice centers on board and senior executive mandates, and its On-Demand Talent business places interim professionals. For permanent retained searches below the executive team, such as national account executives, retail execution managers, or sourcing managers at consumer brands, that is the level Protis Global covers every week.

How do the two firms' fees differ?

Protis Global structures retained fees as milestone-based installments: the second installment triggers only when the firm presents a slate of talent, typically 2 to 3 people, and the client approves them to interview, with the final installment paid upon placement. Heidrick runs conventional retained engagements, so confirm installment triggers in the contract before signing.

Who owns each firm?

Heidrick & Struggles completed a $1.3 billion take-private transaction backed by Advent International and Corvex Private Equity, reported by Hunt Scanlon, and no longer trades on Nasdaq. Protis Global is an independent firm that has worked exclusively in consumer brands for more than three decades.

What should I compare before choosing a retained search firm?

Compare category depth, the role levels the firm actually fills, what triggers each fee installment, and how often you will see candidates. Ask every firm to walk you through its last three searches at your level. The metrics worth tracking during a search are in 8 executive search metrics consumer brands should know.